🚨 Closing Playbook is off today🚨
We’ll be back tomorrow but in the meantime, you can join Diana at 5 p.m. ET, when she’ll cover the Trade of the Day and more [tap to join her]!
There’s a setup developing in semiconductors that perfectly illustrates one of the most frustrating challenges in trading: spotting a textbook breakout that you cannot actually trade.
I have been watching the chip stock ETF (SMH) closely, and Friday marked the breakout point on the daily chart. That should be great news — right?
The problem is execution. When something is already flying, chasing it immediately is a low-probability move. You need a plan that accounts for what happens next — not just what’s happening now.
The Entry Problem Nobody Talks About
Here is what makes this setup tricky. SMH pushed through on the same day the S&P 500 ETF (SPY) made an equivalent move, but SPY did not continue while SMH did.
That divergence creates uncertainty. If SMH decides to take a pause here, finding a clean entry becomes significantly harder.
This is the kind of situation where most traders either freeze or chase, and both options usually end badly. The ideal scenario would be waiting for a pullback to the breakout area, where you get better risk-reward and confirmation that the level is holding. But that requires patience, and it requires accepting that you might miss the move entirely if it doesn’t pull back.
The truth is that even though the structure has been messy, it’s easy to look back and admire the run. From the recent low to this breakout, SMH has already climbed more than 20%. In hindsight it looks obvious, but in real time you’re staring at a chart and asking yourself where an actual entry is supposed to come from in all that noise.
The picture smooths out on higher time frames. The weekly and monthly charts look cleaner, and you can make the case that this is a broader breakout that could keep pushing. But the daily execution still matters, and that’s where things get complicated.
The alternative is constructing a position structure that accounts for the uncertainty. Something like a duckbill could work here, where you’re capturing directional movement with defined risk instead of just buying and hoping. I’m looking at whether the current price levels and premium structure make that approach lucrative enough to justify the position.
Directional Moves Beat Volatile Chop
What I would really like to see is some smooth directionality. We are not going to get a huge gap fill or massive gap up from here — that’s not realistic given where we are in the move. But we can get at least a little bit of directional momentum, which would be a welcome change after the volatility we have dealt with recently.
The key is not forcing it. Yes, the breakout is happening. Yes, the setup looks bullish. But if the entry’s not there, the setup does not matter. This is where discipline separates traders who last from traders who blow up chasing every move that looks good on the chart.
SMH is a perfect example of why having a tactical plan matters more than spotting the setup. Anyone can see the breakout — executing it properly is what counts.
Kane Shieh
Kane Shieh Trading
Follow along and join the conversation for real-time analysis, trade ideas, market insights and more!
Important Note: No one from The TradingPub team or Kane Shieh Trading will ever contact you directly on Telegram.
*This is for informational and educational purposes only. There is inherent risk in trading, so trade at your own risk.
P.S. The Force Controlling the S&P 500’s Daily Finish
Hi, Kane here. If you can keep a secret…
There’s been a major shift in the options market that’s creating a huge opportunity for traders in the know.
And while most folks will likely never hear about this shift, let alone have a chance to profit from it.
This shift has now opened the door to a reliable way to target double- and even triple-digit moves in the stock market every day, regardless of what comes from the Middle East next.
All thanks to a little-known market force that’s now controlling the S&P’s price action most days.
A force that’s been rising in the options market and completely altering how the market moves on a day-to-day basis.
The same force that I’ve been using to pinpoint the market’s likely finish with a stunning 79.4% accuracy.
In the same period, tariffs also bled trillions from the market before the Iran war.
And this Saturday at 11 a.m. ET, I’ll show you how this force actually controls where the S&P 500 will close that day, down to the last dollar.
You’ll see how you can find this force in real time and place trades targeting double- or even triple-digit returns before the close every market day.
I won’t be alone.
My buddy and former hedge fund manager Roger Scott will be at this special event as I spill the secrets.
I won’t make reckless guarantees when it comes to trading.
But while folks would rather focus on the fear narratives the media keeps spinning around every minute…
You can be among the few with inside information on this overlooked force in the S&P 500…
And how you can tap into this same force to target same-day returns.
We develop tools and strategies to the best of our ability, but we can’t guarantee the future. In LIVE trading alerts in real time from 08/23/24 to 3/28/26, the strategy is 54-14, with an overall win rate of 79.4% and an average return (winners and losers included) of 59.3%, with an average winner of 86.8% over a 1-day hold time. Trade at your own risk.
